Handing your tax return to someone else means handing over your Social Security numbers, income details, and bank information — and legally, the return is still yours. If something on it is wrong or made up, the IRS holds you responsible, not the person who typed it. Choosing a preparer deserves more care than picking the closest office or the lowest price.
The good news: the IRS gives you two checks that separate accountable preparers from risky ones, and both take thirty seconds.
Checks one and two: a PTIN, and a signature on your return
Federal rules are plain: anyone who is paid to prepare a federal tax return must have a Preparer Tax Identification Number — a PTIN — issued by the IRS, and must sign your return as the paid preparer and include that PTIN on it. There are no exceptions for part-time preparers, seasonal pop-up offices, or someone who does taxes on the side for pay.
The signature and PTIN in the paid-preparer section are the paper trail tying a real, identifiable person to your filing. Before you hand over a single document, ask for the PTIN and confirm the preparer will sign your return. An honest preparer answers without hesitation.
The ghost preparer: the scam the IRS names every year
A "ghost preparer" takes your documents and your money, prepares the return — then refuses to sign it, leaving the paid-preparer section blank so the return looks self-prepared. The IRS flags ghost preparers in its annual scam warnings, because the pattern comes with inflated refunds and invented deductions. With no signature, the preparer can disappear — and the return is still yours to answer for.
Ghost preparers give themselves away in other ways, too: asking you to sign a blank or unfinished return, promising an unusually large refund before seeing your paperwork, or filing without letting you review the final version. Never sign a blank or incomplete return. Your signature means you reviewed it and believe it is correct.
Credentials, in plain language
Beyond the PTIN, preparers fall into a few groups, and it helps to know what the letters do and do not mean:
- CPAs are accountants licensed by their state through exams and continuing education.
- Enrolled agents (EAs) are licensed by the IRS itself, by examination, and focus on taxes.
- Attorneys are licensed by their state bar; some practice in tax matters.
- PTIN-holding preparers are registered with the IRS and legally allowed to prepare returns for pay — but it is a registration, not a tested credential.
For most families, the letters matter less than the behavior: is the preparer registered, do they sign, do they explain the return to you, and will they still answer the phone in July? The IRS maintains a public Directory of Federal Tax Return Preparers where you can look up preparers who hold a CPA, EA, or attorney credential, or who complete the IRS Annual Filing Season Program each year. If someone claims a credential, a one-minute check there confirms it.
Red flags and good signs
Walk away if a preparer:
- Refuses to sign your return or will not share their PTIN
- Charges a fee based on a percentage of your refund
- Wants your refund deposited into their bank account instead of yours
- Asks you to sign a blank or incomplete return
- Will not give you a complete copy of your filed return
Good signs you are in the right hands:
- They ask for your documents instead of guessing at numbers
- Your fee is confirmed before preparation begins
- They review the finished return with you and answer your questions
- You get a complete copy of everything filed
Questions to ask before you hire
A short conversation up front prevents most filing-season problems. Ask:
- What exactly does your fee include — and is my Georgia state return part of it?
- Who actually prepares my return, and will that person sign it?
- How do I send you my documents, and how are they kept secure?
- How long will my return take once you have everything?
- What do you need from me to get started?
Gather your paperwork first — our W-2 tax filing checklist covers what most employees need. If part of your income comes from freelance or gig work, the 1099-NEC threshold change affects which forms reach you this season — bring whatever arrived.
And make sure Georgia is covered
Most Georgia filers need a state return too, prepared from the same documents as the federal one. When you compare preparers, confirm the state return is included and priced up front, not added as a surprise at the end. If you moved into or out of Georgia during the year, or worked across state lines, mention it early — those filings are routine but change the paperwork. Our individual tax preparation includes your federal return plus one state return, so Georgia is covered from the start.
How SOLVBOOKS works
SOLVBOOKS prepares returns 100% virtually, from Lawrenceville, Georgia, for clients across Georgia and nationwide. You start your return online and upload your documents through a secure client portal. Your identity is verified on a short live video call. Your fee is confirmed before preparation begins — flat, never a percentage of your refund. When your return is ready, we review it with you, you sign electronically, and we e-file it and provide a complete copy for your records.
SOLVBOOKS is an IRS-registered tax preparer (PTIN holder), and every return we prepare is signed, with the PTIN on it — exactly the way the IRS says it should be.
Ready to file with someone accountable?
Choosing a preparer for this season? Call (678) 245-1096 and ask us the questions on this page — starting with the PTIN and the signature. We are glad to answer every one.